drifter601 wrote:Just came back from Wright State Invitational and did pretty well...
However, I dont know if anyone else saw, but the way the proctors measured the clearance was very inaccurate. They had a video camera set up but you could tell it didnt work because after a few tests, the proctors rarely looked at it for a true confirmation. Most of the time, the weight dropped, the 3 proctors discussed for a second (literally 2-3 seconds) and told the competitors the scores. On tests that went way above the camera (40's to 90's cm) you could hear them saying "55 to 65? Right?.... ehhh 60 cm") and then would tell the competitors. This seemed very unfair as any kind of error in vision could put an entire team back a place in overall team results. I hope at Nats, they will have a high-speed camera and some kind of mechanism to test if the weight tapped or not (as suggested in the rules, carbon paper or sand).
Also, the way they had the "5 minute setup" was very unprofessional. They never stated that when teams are in line to test, that waiting time IS you setup time, so many teams had to mark measurements within the 5 minute TESTING period, and had to rush to get both tests on time.
I hope at Nats, they will have a high-speed camera and some kind of mechanism to test if the weight tapped or not (as suggested in the rules, carbon paper or sand).
I know that the proctor at Nats already has that all planned out. He even has a really cool rig to take the parallax into account. That was my main concern from the mira loma invite was how the proctors didnt have a tripod or anything for the camera so they were holding it at different heights. If the camera is not at the exact level as the falling mass and the meter stick (or whatever they are using to measure the distance) is not right next to the mass there will be a parallax issue resulting in slightly incorrect results. That being said i felt that at the invite it wasnt unfair because there weren't a ton of teams who were getting extremely close. (1-10cm to the ground) For the most part it was clear what the rankings were